When my friend Aisha Holmes texted me a few Fridays back to say she had just eaten chicken marinated in sweet tea and pickle juice, I thought I was going to flat-out lose my mind. That sandwich couldn’t be more Southern if it married its cousin, used “fixin’ to” as a verb, and called every soft drink, regardless of brand, a coke. As soon as I read that text, I was completely obsessed and knew I had to replicate this wondrous dish, which from the description I was given, lacked only one thing to make it perfect. And that thing, my friends, is Alabama White Sauce.
OMG. If you’ve never had Alabama White Sauce, first of all, I feel sorry for you. And second, you don’t know what you’re missing. The first time I remember ever had white sauce was from Big Bob Gibson Barbecue in Decatur, Alabama. Friday nights were frequently barbecue nights in the Norwood household, which I now realize also happened to coincide with payday. My mother would pick up a whole roasted chicken, sometimes some pulled pork for sandwiches, and always a bag of crispy fried pork skins. Even as a child, and long before the book or movie had become a phenomenon, the pork skins seemed a little Silence of the Lamby to me, so I never touched them. But the chicken I liked—because it was a vehicle for the white sauce.
The sauce is a many splendored thing, and couldn’t be simpler to make. Mayonnaise, vinegar, sugar, lemon juice, salt and pepper. Some people fancy it up with wine vinegars, horseradish, mustards, what have you. Me, I don’t bother. No sense trying to make a silk purse out of sow’s ear—although I will say I think it’s far superior if you use my homemade mayonnaise as a base. As for the chicken. Shoot. I felt like that chicken needed a little something extra, though it was near perfect as described. So along with the sweet tea and dill pickle juice, I added bread and butter pickle juice from the pickles my brother and sister-in-law had canned (amazing, by the way), and a soupcon of soy sauce for a salty edge and depth of flavor.
It was crazy good and you better holla, because this chicken will slay you. I mean, Game of Thrones-style. It’s amazing! And I’m fairly certain a dill pickle juice marinade really is the secret to Chick Fil A’s famously moist and flavorful chicken, because that is exactly what it reminded me of at first bite. Drizzle on the white sauce, add bread and butter pickles and either a wrap or bun and you have the perfect dish to kick off grilling season in true Southern style. Plus it’s a great way to upcycle your pickle juice after you’ve eaten all the pickles.
Sweet Tea Chicken
4-5 boneless chicken breasts
1 quart sweet tea
Juice from 1 quart jar of dill pickles
Juice from 1 quart jar of bread and butter pickles
1/3 cup soy sauce.